…but not really that surprising:  http://dissenter.firedoglake.com/2012/08/07/court-ruling-brings-end-to-legal-challenge-against-bush-warrantless-wiretapping/

And yet there are still those who criticize the public for not speaking out and getting off their duffs to do anything–where is the justice?  Who are the people obeying the law of the Constitution?  Not the courts–as someone pointed out, this is the Ninth Circuit–a court that the rightwing continually blasts as “liberal”.  Pffft.